Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Oops!

Supporters of asylum tend to also support liberal immigration rules.  But the Center for Immigration Studies suggests that you can't always have both:
Open borders are rendering some asylum claims arguably pointless, particularly when it comes to claims based on fear of gangs.

An activist group has joined forces with a law firm in pressuring DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano and Attorney General Eric Holder to overturn a recent immigration court decision that denied an asylum claim by a number of young Salvadoran aliens. The youths claimed that they had fled their country in 2004 because of threats from the violent gang Mara Salvatrucha, aka MS-13. The relevant documents are available here.

In recommending the granting of asylum, the aliens' expert witness testified that El Salvador's police are not capable of controlling MS-13 and as a result the gang grows through forcible recruitment of youths who live within an MS-13 controlled zone.

But can the United States be considered a safe haven from such recruitment efforts? Due to lax border security, our own law enforcement is not doing a spectacular job of stopping the spread of MS-13. As the Center for Immigration Studies documented in a recent report on gangs and immigration law, "Taking Back the Streets," MS-13 recruitment efforts in the United States are at an all-time high as measured by the gang's growth and nationwide expansion. The Central American immigrant communities here in the United States are routinely threatened by MS-13 gang crime and young children are prime targets for violence and recruitment.



Will REAL ID be replaced by Enhanced Drivers Licenses?

It's clear that Sec. Napolitano would like to trade EDLs for Real ID.

Nice idea.  EDLs have been voluntarily adopted by several states.  Can we get the states to adopt high standards for license security by offering the honey of easier border crossing instead of the vinegar of harder flight boarding? 

In a word, no.  I don't see how EDLs can be a substitute for REAL ID.  If they aren't mandatory, lots of people will opt to get regular drivers' licenses that don't meet high security standards.  And as long as low-security licenses are available, those are the documents that terrorists and identity thieves will use, too. 

There's another problem.  EDLs have an RFID chip in them.  For a good reason:  the chips are used at the border to speed travel.  But they aren't needed elsewhere, certainly not in all drivers licenses.  Why raise the anxieties of anti-RFID campaigners if you don't need to?  Trying to make EDLs a substitute for Real ID will feed the fears of those who suspect that EDLs are the thin edge of the wedge, and that the real goal is to "chip" everyone.  Since that's not true, why feed the fantasy?


Tuesday, February 24, 2009

European law enforcement ups the pressure on Skype

Eurojust will be investigating VOIP --

Here's why, according to Eurojust:
Criminals in Italy are increasingly making phone calls over the internet in order to avoid getting caught through mobile phone intercepts. Police officers in Milan say organised crime, arms and drugs traffickers, and prostitution rings are turning to Skype and other systems of VoIP in order to frustrate investigators. Skype's encryption system is a secret which the company refuses to share with the authorities. Investigators have become increasingly reliant on wiretaps in recent years. Customs and tax police in Milan have highlighted the Skype issue. They overheard a suspected cocaine trafficker telling an accomplice to switch to Skype in order to get details of a 2kg drug consignment.


Monday, February 23, 2009

Esther Olavarria takes (new) DAS job for immigration policy

Visa Waiver Worries

FBI Director Mueller, in a speech to the Council on Foreign Relations, acknowledges that visa-waiver countries are a terrorism risk:

Today, we still face threats from al Qaeda. But we must also focus on less well-known terrorist groups, as well as homegrown terrorists. And we must consider extremists from visa-waiver countries, who are merely an e-ticket away from the United States.


Lots of us agree. But Andrew Cochran goes off the deep end when he says that we should get rid of the VWP entirely.

Now if Director Mueller would only go further by admitting that the only "good" Visa Waiver Program is a "dead" Visa Waiver Program.
Since Andrew's advisors left government, we've done a lot to improve security in the VWP, and once the airlines do their part by implementing two-way communications with DHS, we will be able to use ESTA to vet VWP travelers before they can even get on the plane. If we did away with the program, tourism would tank, and we'd get two, count 'em, two additional security measures: we would have fingerprints before the traveler got on the plane instead of right after the traveler gets off the plane; and we'd be required by law to interview every single traveler.

If the first measure is really that useful, we could require that travelers provide their prints before getting on board. Frankly, I'm a bit skeptical, but there's no need to get rid of the program just to collect prints. As for the interviews -- we'd have lines around the block in Paris and London, or a radical drop in tourism, or both. And how much do you think we'd learn by interviewing millions under such pressure? Again, I'm skeptical. Now that we have ESTA, we can pick out the people we really want to interview and tell them to get a visa. Makes for better interviews and fewer hassles. Why the determination to kill the program when it's clearly salvageable?



Vast new amounts of "public" data could become actual public data

If we could lteach search engines to understand the public databases on the web.  I'd like to say something smart about the public policy implications of this.  But I don't actually know what they'll be. Apart from putting a whole bunch of airline ticket search sites out of business.


Sunday, February 22, 2009

Talk about mixed feelings

Cory Doctorow has a plausible summary of How the Internet Will Devour, Transform, or Destroy Your Favorite Medium.  On the block:  music, big budget movies, books, and newspapers.

But I think Cory missed the industry that may be killed first by the Internet.  Radio.  XM is just the start.  Cost cutting has hurt variety and maybe quality of radio broadcasts.  And the competition is getting tougher:  in my life, cheap music and Pandora and, most of all, podcasts and audible.com have crowded out radio almost completely.  Even NPR gets no more than 3 minutes of bumpf before I flick to the mp3 player. 

I think radio -- or maybe just the spectrum it uses -- is going to have to find a new mission.